Travel Tips & Trip Ideas Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

View all Travel Tips & Trip Ideas activity »
  1. 1 Oregon coast trip destination advise please
  2. 2 A problem with booking.com
  3. 3 First solo trip, where should I visit?
  4. 4 Do you get your expired passport back?
  5. 5 Museum exhibitions
  6. 6 Best way to find new things to do in new city/country?
  7. 7 Best place for a solo traveler to find a travel partner
  8. 8 Best time to purchase ticket on British Air
  9. 9 Wheeled duffle options
  10. 10 Grad trip: African Safari vs. Europe
  11. 11 Fodor's: Please Stop with the Obnoxious Ads
  12. 12 Newbie Using Whats App
  13. 13 TripIt App?
  14. 14 Watch Out! There are VRBO.com Fees!
  15. 15 Money transfer
  16. 16 Itinerary Planning Apps
  17. 17 Why Do People Bother With Tripadvisor?
  18. 18 In search of international vacation ideas with toddler from NYC
  19. 19 Passport signature
  20. 20 Need advice! First time to Ireland, 10 day itinerary set
  21. 21 Switzerland-Paris10 days trip...queries
  22. 22 St. Louis MO to Yellowstone
  23. 23 May or June trip ideas with 2 adult children
  24. 24 Outdoorsy but with shopping
  25. 25 Travel ideas near spring break?
View next 25 » Back to the top

Why Do People Bother With Tripadvisor?

Jump to last reply

The site is such a joke. Mixing ratings by 20 year old backpackers, middle class insurance salesmen from Dubuque with sophisticated, wealthy older travelers average out to meaningless numbers.

I just checked their ratings on where I live, which is a 3rd tier tourist destination, and a few paces where I used to live. The ratings were laughable. The top rated restaurants were half places that I never heard of and few if any were places that a local would consider a top restaurant in town. Out of the top 10, maybe 1 or 2 might make some local person's list.

On things to do, it's really laughable. Locals would bother with few if any items. Raters would putting things like those Dinner Theaters in the top 10. dinner theater. Even in big tourist cities, the ratings make no sense. Look at Venice, for example. Something called Interpreti Veneziani ranks #1. Huh? St Mark's is #10? Any rational individual would have it as #1. Meanwhile Musica A Palazzo is #3?

In sum, Tripadvisor just doesn't work. Numbers can't capture a placeThe whole thing is based on self selection. A small group with a special interest rate something high so it comes out on top. Or 20 years old think its just great and make it tops. Everyone else would find it dull.

Still, there are people who love to count and think that a the #4 place in Rome must be better than the #8 place. The numbers make life simple because now there is no need to think. Just follow the rail of breadcrumbs. I'd rather just read the free flowing type of discussion on Fodors. It's not as simple as counting numbers, but then planning a trip isn't simple

153 Replies | Jump to bottom Add a Reply
153 Replies |Back to top

Sign in to comment.

Advertisement